Costa Pizzeria Menu

Italian plate


italian plate

Served with our signature bread.
Dressing: Italian, French, Greek, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Ranch, Creamy Caesar, Oil & Vinegar, Balsamic Vinaigrette

Gourmet Pizza

italian plate

Baked Pasta

italian plate

Served with Garden Salad & our Signature Bread. Add Meatball or Meat Sauce for 2.95. Gluten Free Pasta add 3.00 extra


italian plate
  • Can of Soda $1.50
  • 2 Liter $3.50
  • Snapple $2.50
  • Vitamin Water $2.50
  • Nantucket Nectar $2.50
  • Foxon Park $2.50
  • Sparkling Water $2.50
  • Alcohol Free Heineken $2.50

Choice of Service

italian plate

Dine In




Italian grapes

Happy Customers!

"Pizza the way it should be! Delicious thin crust, loaded with sauce, cheese, and toppings. A traditional New York style pizza the way I remember it."

- Geroge Lotridge

"I’ve experienced nothing but the best service and absolutely great food from here. They are very personable with everyone and they tend to remember what you like. If I could give more than 5 stars, I would."

- Marly Montanez

"Absolutely love Costa! Definitely our favorite pizza place in new haven. They offer a HUGE array of VEGAN options along with the regular menu. The staff is kind and thoughtful and the pizza is always awesome! And great crust!! Do yourself a favor and go to Costa!"

- Kay Pelletier

"Great pizza. Open until late. Nice people. The delivery is always fast. Inexpensive."

- Angel Garcia

"The vegan grinders are amazing! My family says that all of the other food is delicious too. Very friendly service."

- Ean Pringle

Subscribe To Costa's Newsletter